Medicare beneficiaries may elect to join an HMO as an alternative to traditional fee-for-service Medicare.  Medicare HMOs contract with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid to provide the full range of Medicare-covered services to Medicare beneficiaries for a fixed monthly fee from the government. Generally you have coverage for care only from providers who are part of the HMO network. The only exceptions are for emergency services, which you may receive anywhere in the United States, and urgently needed services, which you may receive while temporarily away from your HMO's service area. Therefore, if you spend part of the year (more than 90 days) outside the HMO's service plan area, joining an HMO may not be in your best interest.

When you first enroll in an HMO, you will be asked to select a primary care physician from the HMO's list of doctors. A primary care doctor is responsible for managing all of your medical care, including referrals to a specialist like a cardiologist or gastroenterologist, when your doctor thinks you need it.  Some HMOs offer a Point of Service (POS) option for an additional cost. Under the POS option, you will be allowed to see providers outside the network, and the HMO usually pays 70 or 80% of the cost.

Some HMOs also offer coverage for services that Original Medicare doesn’t provide, including routine physical exams, dental benefits, eyeglasses and hearing aids.

Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) are the most common type of Medicare Advantage plans. Other types of managed care plans are Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) and Private Fee-for-Service Plans (PFFS).

The Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) has the flexibility to determine how the benefits will be offered, but they must provide all of the benefits available under Medicare Parts A and B.  Therefore applicants need to review plan materials carefully.

You only use doctors, specialists and hospitals on the PPO plan’s list (network).  You do not need referrals to specialists.  You can go to doctors, specialists, or hospitals not on the list, but access to providers outside the network are at higher cost-sharing amounts than network providers.

Unlike HMOs, the PPOs have no capacity limits.  Consequently, they will be able to enroll all beneficiaries who wish to enroll.       

Private Fee-for-Service Plan permit members to obtain services from any Medicare approved participating provider who accepts its payment rates.  Providers who accept a PFFS rate for one service may refuse it for another.  Beneficiaries are generally responsible for a percentage of the accepted rates.  PFFS rates may be higher than Medicare rates.

Centers for Medicare and Medicaid (CMS) Publication #10144-Your Guide to Private Fee-for-Service Plans state the following important information:

     “Private Fee-for-Service Plans may let providers (such a doctors or hospitals) charge you 15% over the plan’s payment amounts for services.  This 15% balance billing amount applies to providers who have a written contract with the Private Fee-for-Service Plan or who the company has decided to think of as having a contract (deemed) because they have met certain conditions.  Ask if your Private Fee-for-Service Plan allows providers to balance bill.”

Therefore, I suggest the following:

Before shopping and /or making a decision on a PFFS policy, the client becomes PFFS-literate.  Therefore, I recommend the above CMS publication #10144, “Your Guide to Fee-for-Service Plans” (call 1-800-Medicare for the publication).  And the info will enable you to ask questions about the available plans.

PFFS is new to New York City, so I have no “hands on” experience.

Please refer to HMO segment 05 for a “closer look” at benefits and cost sharing at HMOs and PPOs in Manhattan (New York County).  My analysis may be helpful in choosing a plan.  

Updated: January 29, 2007

 

 

Next Page>>